Monday, February 27, 2012

"Act of Valor" Wins Box Office War

As I predicted last November, the professional movie critics generally panned "Act of Valor," which only received a 30% positive score on Rotten Tomatoes (and only 20% amongst "Top Critics.")

Also, not surprisingly, the film has been much, much more popular with actual audiences, grossing $24.7 million and winning the box office race this weekend.

I think these numbers reflect the divide between America's masses and the "elites" represented by the film critics.  As I noted in my review, the movie:
is a much-needed break from Hollywood’s unbearably patronizing treatment of the U.S. military since 9/11, in which U.S. troops are alternately depicted as either marauders or as victims instead of heroes
Whereas critics think these depictions illustrate depth, I think the public rightly sees them as condescending and shuns such films versus movies that aren't afraid to depict our fighinting men (and women) as the heroes they are.

Drone Casualties Less Than Believed?

An interesting report by the Associated Press claiming that the number of civilians killed by U.S. drone strikes in Pakistan is much lower than claimed by Pakistani opponents of the campaign, as well as other media reporting, a subject I've discussed previously.
Although the AP's methodology is still somewhat inexact, they come up with the same figure for total casualties as reported by Pakistani intelligence.  Yet the AP reporters find that, excluding one attack that allegedly killed 38 civilians on March 17, 2011, Pakistani villagers interviewed say 90 percent of the victims of all other people killed were militants.  Conversely, the London-based "Bureau of Investigative Journalism" has claimed the percentage of militants killed is roughly 70 to 80 percent. 

Pakistan Tears Down Abbottabad Compound

Well, damn!!!  I was definitely planning on making a stop there on my next trip to Pakistan, but apparently Osama bin Laden's Abbottabad compound is no more. 

If the Pakistanis were smart they could have given the compound the full Disney treatment, wherein tourists were transported to the house via helicopter, holes suddenly appeared in walls as if they were blown clear, the sound of gunfire would be piped in the courtyard over loudspeakers, and then people would rush up to the top floor to be greeted by an animatronic bin Laden who ducks back into his room. 

You can't tell me that wouldn't have been a serious moneymaker!!!

Pakistani excavators demolish bin Laden's Abbottabad compound.

Tuesday, February 21, 2012

What Did Pakistan Know About Bin Laden?

Fresh on the heels of former ISI chief Ziauddin Butt's charge that former Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf knew Osama bin Laden was hiding in Abbottabad, David Ignatius reports that the architect who worked on the Abbottabad compound was regularly employed by the ISI.  Ignatius goes on to propose an interesting set of questions regarding how bin Laden came to be living in Abbottabad in a large house one mile from Pakistan's premier military academy, to be investigated by a special civilian commission in Pakistan.

Separately, Jeffrey Goldberg comments in the Atlantic as to why the Pakistani military's commission examining this exact question has yet to determine an answer, suggesting the commission has devoted more time investigating Pakistanis accused of helping U.S. intelligence prepare for the SEALs' raid than finding out who was hiding bin Laden.

Monday, February 20, 2012

Today in Manhunting History -- February 20, 2005: Zarqawi's High-Speed Chase

Shortly after al-Qa'ida in Iraq's failed attempt to disrupt the first free Iraqi elections in January 2005, the Joint Special Operations Task Force learned that Abu Musab al-Zarqawi would be travelling on a particular stretch of road alongside the Tigris between Fallujah and Ramadi on 20 February. Delta operators and Rangers set up an ambush and waited, but Zarqawi was late. Believing they had received another false lead, the operators began packing up when a vehicle blew through Delta’s roadblock and came bearing down on the checkpoint manned by the Rangers. The Ranger M240B machine-gunner had the SUV in his sights and requested permission to fire. But the lieutenant in charge hesitated, refusing clearance because he lacked positive identification of the vehicle’s occupants. The vehicle roared past the checkpoint with Zarqawi staring wildly out the window, clutching an American assault rifle.

The Delta operators quickly took off in hot pursuit while a Shadow unmanned aerial vehicle tracked the high-speed chase from above. Zarqawi was “shitting his pants,” one operator later recalled. “He was screaming at the driver. He knew he was caught.” With the Task Force operators about 30 seconds behind, Zarqawi’s driver pulled off the main highway and onto a secondary road. The Shadow’s camera showed the vehicle slowing down. An occupant jumped out and disappeared into a nearby field as the SUV sped off.  

Inside the command center, a split second decision had to be made: should the Shadow follow the vehicle or the runner? The officer in charge, likely reasoning that the truck could move faster than the man on foot, kept the UAV on the moving vehicle.

Unfortunately, Zarqawi was the runner. When the Delta operators caught the truck, they captured his driver, another terrorist, $100,000 in Euros, and his laptop. The hard drive contained everything from tactical information to Zarqawi’s photographs of himself, which he stored in the banally titled file “My Pictures.” But Zarqawi disappeared into the shadows once again.

Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, the murderous leader of al-Qa'ida in Iraq, was in U.S. gunsights and nearly captured on this day in 2005.



Sunday, February 19, 2012

Today in Manhunting History -- February 19, 1917: The Death of Frederick Funston

As pressure increased for America to enter World War I, Major General Frederick Funston -- hero of the hunt for Philippine insurgent leader Emilio Aguinaldo in 1901 -- emerged as the leading candidate to command the American Expeditionary Force.

On February 19, 1917, Secretary of War Baker threw a dinner party at his home with President Wilson as guest of honor. Major Douglas MacArthur, the son of Funston’s former commander in the Philippines, was on night watch duty for the General Staff. Peyton March, now a lieutenant colonel, was also on staff duty that night. At about 10PM, March brought MacArthur a telegram that both officers agreed was important enough to be delivered to Baker at once. MacArthur writes:

When I reached the Secretary’s home, the butler refused to let me enter, saying that he had orders to admit no one. The dining room looked out on the entrance hall and I could see it plainly. It was a gay party, with lights and laughter, the tinkle of glasses, the soft music from an alcove, the merry quips and jokes of a cosmopolitan group. I finally pushed by the butler and tried to attract the attention of the Secretary so I could report to him privately what had occurred. But the President saw me and sang out in the most jovial manner, “Come in, Major, and tell all of us the news. There are no secrets here.” There was a general clapping of hands at this, and I knew I was in for it. So clicked my heels together, saluted him, and barked in a drill-sergeant tone, “Sir, I regret to report that General Funston has just died.” Had the voice of doom spoken, the result could not have been different. The silence seemed like that of death itself. You could hear your own breathing. Then, I never saw such a scattering of guests in my life. It was a stampede.

Frederick S. Funston had survived the extremities of deserts, tundra, and jungles, multiple tropical diseases, and five wounds from enemy fire. While sitting in the lobby of the Saint Anthony Hotel in San Antonio, he heard an orchestra playing, and commented “How beautiful it all is,” when his own heart finally failed him at the age of 51. His body was the first to ever lay in state at the Alamo, before eventually being buried at the Presidio.

With Funston’s passing, “Black Jack” Pershing became the logical choice to command the American Expeditionary Force in France. He successfully led U.S. forces to victory in World War I, and was rewarded in 1919 with promotion to the artificial rank of six-star “General of the Armies,” a grade occupied only by himself and the posthumously promoted George Washington.


Major General Frederick Funston, 1865-1917



Friday, February 17, 2012

"The Americans are here, Our saviors are here, Let's dance!"

Alan Boswell of McClatchy has an interesting update on the U.S. special forces hunt for Lord's Resistance Army leader Joseph Kony that is worth a read.  The Green Berets are providing logistical support, bolstering intelligence sharing, and improving coordination amongst the four indigenous armies pursuing Kony and the LRA, making this manhunt similar to the hunt for Che Guevara.

Boswell notes "There are differing opinions among officials about whether killing or capturing Kony would be enough to end his movement."  Indeed, I would argue that we will not be successful in achieving our broader strategic (or in this case, humanitarian) objective unless we also take out the other senior leaders of the LRA at the same time.